| Year | Winner | 1st Runner Up | 2nd Runner Up |
| 1998 | Rusty Thornsburg | Monica Combrink | Stephanie Rust |
| 1999 | Stephanie Rust | Monica Combrink | Marc Loberg |
| 2000 | Monica Combrink | Nicole Grzeskowiak | Marc Loberg |
| 2001 | Nicole Grzeskowiak | Beth Rocha | Christopher Rust |
| 2002 | Stephanie Strauss | Joe Devous | Kristen Laing |
| 2003 | Amanda Cummings | Kory Kuntz & Kristen Laing | Joe Devous |
| 2004 | Kristen Laing | Allison Grzeskowiak | Joshua Winzer |
| 2005 | Joshua Winzer | Kelly D. Norris | Rachel Hindle |
| 2006 | Grace Farley | Sarah M. Green | Geoffrey Hewett |
| 2007 | Gabriel Lockhart | Allison Grzeskowiak | Sean Pennington |
| 2008 | Allison Grzeskowiak | Sarah Green | Sean Pennington |
| 2009 | Luke Dreyer | Alex Harding tied with | Sean Pennington |
| 2010 | Alexander Harding | Sarah Green | Sean Pennington |
| 2011 | Claire Harding | Sarah Green | Megan Pennington |
| 2012 | Megan Pennington | Colin Campbell | Faith Winzer |
| 2013 | Colin Campbell | Sarah Green | Faith Winzer |
| 2014 | Faith Winzer | Sarah Green | Hope Winzer |
| 2015 | Sarah M. Green | Glory Winzer | Hope Winzer |
| 2016 | Amberlee Pick | Hope Winzer | Glory Winzer |
| 2017 | Hope Winzer | Glory Winzer | Katharina Brase |
| 2018 | Michael Kowalchyk | Katharine Brase | Glory Winzer |
